ಅವಳ ಬಳಿ ಅನೇಕ ಸೊಗಸಾದ ಜರಿ ಸೀರೆಗಳಿವೆ. ಈಗ ಅವನ್ನು ಉಟ್ಟು ಮೆರೆಯುವ, ಸಂತೋಷ ಪಡುವ ವಯಸ್ಸು. ಆದರೆ ಅವನ್ನು ಪೆಟ್ಟಿಗೆಗಳಲ್ಲಿ ಮಡಿಸಿಟ್ಟು, ನುಸು ಗುಳಿಗೆಗಳ ಕಂಪನ್ನು ಕೊಟ್ಟು, ಆಗಾಗ ತೆಗೆದು ನೋಡಿ ಸಂತೋಷ ಪಡುತ್ತಾಳೆ. ಆಸೆಗಣ್ಣಿಂದ ನೋಡುವ ಅಕ್ಕ ತಂಗಿಯರಿಗೂ ಒಮ್ಮೆಯೂ ಉಡಲು ಕೊಡುವುದಿಲ್ಲ. ವರ್ಷಗಳ ನಂತರ ಇಟ್ಟಲ್ಲೇ, ಮಡಿಸಿಟ್ಟ ಕಡೆಯೇ, ಆ ಸೀರೆಗಳು ತೂತು ಬೀಳುತ್ತವೆ. ಆಥವಾ ಅವು ಚೆನ್ನಾಗಿದ್ದರೂ ಇವಳಿಗೆ ಉಡುವ ಕಾಲ ದಾಟಿತು. "ಅಬ್ಬಾ, ಇವೆಷ್ಟು ಭಾರ. ನಾನು ಉಡಲಾರೆನಮ್ಮ" ಎಂದು ನಿಟ್ಟುಸಿರು ಬಿಡುತ್ತಾಳೆ. ಇದೇ ಜಿಪುಣತ್ವದ ಪರಿಣಾಮ. "ತಾನೂ ತಿನ್ನ. ಪರರಿಗೂ ಕೊಡ" ಎನ್ನುವ ಗಾದೆ ಹುಟ್ಟಿದ್ದೇ ಇಂತಹವರನ್ನು ಸೂಚಿಸಲು.
Monday, July 1, 2024
ಪಕೋಡ ಮತ್ತು ಆಸೆ
Friday, June 28, 2024
Undeclared "Emergency"?
FOURTEEN major banks were nationalised in India on 19th July, 1969. Management control of the banks was moved to the state from the private ownerships. Punjab National Bank (PNB) was one of these major banks. Bank started its operations in the year 1895 on "Baishakhi Day" (12th April, 1895) at Lahore of undivided Punjab province (presently in Pakistan), by Punjab Kesari Lala Lajpat Roy and his associates, It was the first Indian bank started entirely with Indian capital and management. The bank was a product of "Nationalist Movement" and hence the name "National" in its name. It was a north based bank till nationalisation, but grew all over the country after nationalisation due to branch expansion in different parts of the country thereafter. Today it is one of the biggest banks in the country in terms of branches, deposits and assets.
The growth of Trade Union Movement in India runs parallel to the growth of banking industry in India. This bank also had and even now has its employees union. Each state has a state union which are affiliated to the All India Federation under the name "All India PNB Employees Federation" (AIPNBEF). The Federation holds its conventions periodically and delegates and observes from all over the country participate in such conferences, review its performance over the past period, set its goals for the next period and elect its leaders for the coming tenure. The conventions are held in different parts of the country and are hosted by one of the state units, as decided by the national leadership. As hundreds of delegates and observers participate in the three day conference, lot of resources and manpower was naturally required for hosting these conferences successfully.
One such conference was due to be held in 1975. In the state of Karnataka, PNB had a token presence of 12 branches with 4 of them in Bangalore and the other 8 in some major district headquarters. Total membership of the Karnataka unit of the union was 120. In the Central Committee meeting of the Federation held in Delhi in January, 1975, our leader proposed to host the conference. The central leadership appreciated the enthusiasm of the Karnataka unit, but felt hosting 700 delegates and observers would be too big a task for a unit with only 120 members. The offer of another northern state unit was accepted.
In the month of March, 1975 we received a telephonic message, followed by a letter, that due to internal problems of the unit that was supposed to host the conference in June, the task was now assigned to us! The dates were also finalised by them and advised to us. June 26-28, 1975 were the dates for the conference. We had just 3 months for the preparation and execution. We went ahead with the task and for the record, it was one of the best conference held by the Federation till then. Having been a principal office-bearer of the host unit managing the finances for the conference, i have seen these developments closely and with minute details.
The inaugural session for the conference was fixed on the afternoon of Thursday, 26th June, 1975. Bangalore's Town Hall was booked as the venue. The delegates session on the next two days were for members only, but inaugural session was a open session with participation from leading personalities of the city, trade union leaders from central trade unions, leaders of other bank unions, and general public. We were busy on the whole night of 25th June tying buntings and flags, and pasting posters at the venue of the conference and nearby areas. When the sun rose in the morning, he was to bring a big day for us!!
On the morning of 26th we were in for a rude shock. Prime Minister Indira Gandhi had declared "National Emergency" on the previous day. Newspapers carried big black headlines, with blank spaces for editorials as press censorship was imposed. Many of the dignitaries who were to participate in the inaugural session were either arrested or were invited to the special meeting convened by the government at Delhi on that day. The inaugural session of the conference was conducted as scheduled with the participation of other available dignitaries, 700 delegates and observers and other participants. A variety entertainment program that ended with a dance-drama "Mohini-Bhasmasura" by "Prabhat Kalavidaru" was widely appreciated. The inaugural session was a great success as was the delegates session on the next two days.
*****
They were the days of limited communication tools. Present internet based media, television or social media were not heard of. The only communication was of letters, newspapers and telephone. Telephone was also available to a limited section of people. Most of the bank unions were affiliated to the communist parties and hence the top leadership attended the meeting on "Joint Consultative Machinery" called by th government. Initially they backed emergency, but towards end of 1976, things changed. The excesses of emergency era and disillusionment with the state control on civil liberties made them to move away from the government. General elections were held in 1977 and the incumbent government was defeated. A new political party by name "Janata Party" was formed by a merger of various political parties and came to power.
The new party could not come out of internal contradictions and the government fell nuch before its mandate for 5 years. Rest is history now.
*****
The words "Constitution" "Democracy" and "Emergency" are in great use during these few months. 25th June that came and went last week marked the 50th Anniversary of Emergency promulgated on the day mentioned above. After the recent elections to the Lok Sabha, many people are moving around with a copy of the Constitution in their hands. The shout of "Democracy is in danger!" is reverberating since many years and the shouting has become shriller nowadays. "Protect constitution" is the demand of everybody and common man does not even know who is protecting it from whom! One fourth-time Lok Sabha member has even said that imposition of emergency in 1975 was at the most undemocratic, but not unconstitutional. Many of the emergency victims who went on to become political leaders of significance later on now declare that it is too old and need not be even mentioned, much less remembering its 50th anniversary! At the same time another group is carying on nationwide protests against emergency and its memory. Some others are crying hoarse that there is an "Undeclared Emergency" in the country.
In this background, it is worthwhile to make a test check of the provisions of emergency and its features to understand whether this cry of undeclared emergency is true or not.
Article 353 of the Constitution mentions that National Emergency can be imposed in three circumstances:
- War is declared by some forces on the country.
- There is external aggression.
- There is internal disturbance. (This was replaced by "armed rebellion" by the 44th amendment to the constitution in 1978)
- Central government can give executive directions to the states.
- Legislative powers of the states are suspended.
- Parliament can enact on subjects under state list as well.
- Central government can pass ordinances on state subjects.
- Life of Lok Sabha or State Assemblies can be extended.
- Distrubition of revenue can be altered.
- Six fundamental rights given under Article 19 get suspended.
- Abuse of authority.
- Undermining democracy.
- Violation of civil rights.
- Threat to federalism.
- Long term damage to the democratic ethos of the country.
- Potential for authoritarianism.
- Attempts for extension of life of Lok Sabha or state legislature has not taken place. Elections are being held regularly at all levels, except for J&K after abrogation of Article 370. Here also elections have taken place for Lok Sabha and state elections are being notified shortly.,
- All state governments are functioning normally. There have been change of power in many states after elections many times in the recent past.
- There are no instances of restrictions of legislative powers of the states.
- Distribution of revenue is taking place as per the recommendations of the Finance Commission.
- Civil rights are not curtailed. People are free to approach courts. There are examples of even the highest court opening in the middle of the night to hear petitions. High priced lawyers are able to file petitions before courts within hours of arrest of some people. Anticipatory bail is freely sought and given in many cases. Appeals are being filed regularly, heard and disposed by courts.
- There is no press censorship and the media is free to publish and telecast even fake news!
- There are some instances of courts admonishing the prosecuting authorities as well.
- When some political leaders are arrested, due to enforcement of laws enacted earlier but kept dormant at implementation stage, their supporters are able to hold demonstrations, block roads and disrupt common man's life, which could not have been heard in an emergency.
- There were nearly 90 instances of dismissing state governments by the centre since the constitution came into force, but there are no such instances in the last decade.
Wednesday, June 26, 2024
The Question Of "Question Papers"
Sunday, June 23, 2024
Three Houses And Two Snakes
- To closely study the snake and find out whether it is poisonous or not. If it is non-poisonous, they need not worry much about it.
- To nominate one of the family members to attend a "Catching Snakes and dealing with them" training program, to be in readiness to deal with the consequences of any untoward happening.
- To make a "First Aid Box" and keep all items required to deal with snake bites so that it comes in literally handy in case of such eventuality.
- To designate one of the family members as "Snake Coordinator" and update him with any further suggestions that may occur to family members later on. The coordinator should also issue "Weekly Bulletin" covering all emergent issues.
- To find out the mobile number of Chikka Nagaraja, famous snake catcher of Bangalore and note the number on the wall of the house prominently, so that he can be called for emergency help.
- The family member also informed that the well-known Snake Nagaraja, who had 15 years experience in catching snakes had died on Saturday, 29th April, 2017 in Jigani while catching a big Cobra. Though he had caught thousands of snakes in his career and had a world record, he finally died by snake bite. The family member also quoted the well known sentence: "He who lives by the sword dies by the sword". He who lived by catching snakes unfortunately died while catching a snake, (Now Chikka Nagaraja had taken the place of the original Nagaraja and was about to beat the snake catching record of the original Nagaraja).
- He also suggested all members of the family to Google about "Snake catcher Nagaraja" for knowing further details.
- House Number 1 represents institutions which do not know that there is a risk element in the system. Life goes on fine until the risk strikes and the institution gets into deep trouble.
- House Number 2 represents institutions which worry about non-existent risks and see a risk everywhere, without actually doing anything about them. They fail to grow because of such attitude.
- House Number 3 represents institutions that have actual risks, but are also aware of its existence. They take action, falter in the beginning, but ultimately evolve sound Risk Management Framework.
Thursday, June 20, 2024
Have We Come A Full Circle?
It was a Friday morning some fifty two years ago, in the early seventies. I was still a teenager and had just landed a bank job and was in the first week of learning new things. Everything was naturally new. I had just realised that banking was much more than receiving and paying out cash. It took only two days to understand that much of banking transactions happen without cash playing any role in them. As it happens with everyone in a new job, I had a mentor who volunteered to teach me various aspects of working in a bank branch. He liked me for two reasons; first because I was new and hence would not resist any work assigned to me, and secondly due to my good handwriting. As everything was done manually and thee was no imagination of computers, someone with a good handwriting was in great demand. One of the tests made before offering a job in the industry was writing neatly, especially in figures (numbers), irrespective of the writer's figure.
As I entered the branch in the morning, some half an hour before the business hours being new to the job, my mentor called me to his table. I was to sit on the counter chair. Seniority in the branch was very visible. Juniors were assigned counter seats whereas the seniors had the privilege of independent tables and chairs behind the counter.
"Did you have a good breakfast today?" he asked.
"Yes Sir. As usual"
"What did you eat?"
"Not much Sir. Only Two Idlies and one Vada, one Chow Chow Bath (a mix of Kesari Bath and Khara Bath or Uppittu) and one Masala Dosa. Of cource, filter coffee."
" Today is Friday. Hence I asked"
"What is special today, Sir?"
"Each working day we open the books in the morning and close at the end of the day after all transactions. on Friday, we not only conclude the day's transactions, but also prepare a balance sheet and send it to Head Office and Regional Office. It is known as "Weekly Statement of Affairs". In short it is popularly called as "Weekly". We have to prepare it, take copies and send by post today itself. It naturally gets a bit late today. Today you are going to do it. Hence a good breakfast and lunch is required!"
I was also excited and prepared the weekly statement under his guidance. Fortunately it was smooth and tallied in first attempt. Copies were taken and the Assistant Manager took it to the Manager's cabin for his final signature. After a few minutes I was called inside. I was asked to sit. We did not sit before the Manager unless he asked ius to do so. Manager said that he was happy it was done neatly and quickly, though it was my first attempt. Discussion went on between him Assistant manager now.
"I am happy that we have come to profit this month".
"Who worries about profit Sir? They look to Deposits and Priority Sector Advances only. They were looking at Profit before Nationalisation".
"No, no. Profit is also equally important even now, though not as much as three years ago.. They don't look at us kindly in monthly meetings, if we are from a loss making branch".
It was early years of "Bank Nationalisation". Resource mobilisation and Priority Sector Lending were key parameters.
We had dinner together happily. Later my mentor took me to Railway Station. We waited for the mail train to Bangalore. There used to be a RMS (Railway Mail Service) bogie in these trains. There was also provision to post letters in a opening of the bogie after affixing additional stamp of five paise. We mailed the two envelopes and went home (room). Sending weekly statement had such sanctity in those days. On alternate Fridays, known as "Reporting Friday"' banks consolidated these statements received from all branches and prepared one for the bank as a whole, and sent it to Reserve Bank of India.
*****
By early 1990s, I was myself a Branch Manager for several years. New Prudential Norms were introduced and the concept of NPA took birth. Profitability became a key issue. Banks even thought of shrinking balance sheets to achieve higher profitability. Branch Managers from loss making branches had vey uncomfortable times in meetings.
There were workshops, seminars and training programs for "Turnaround of Loss making Branches". "Branch Rationalisation" was the buzz word and loss making branches were either closed or merged with others. Even some banks got merged with bigger banks when there was no hope of turnaround for them was felt impossible. "Loss" became a dirty word even if it was in Red Ink. Black was beautiful as it signified Profit.
Some banks that had the potential to turnaround but needed some care for an interval of time were prevented from making fresh advances as the basic reason for losses was bad loans portfolio. Banking has three activities; deposit mobilisation and the deployment of such funds as loans and investments. Since these banks were denied the avenue of lending and their operations were narrowed to the two activities of deposit mobilisation and investments, mostly in government securities, this was also called as "Narrow Banking".
Profit was all important then. Among all the lines "Bottom Line" became very important again.
*****
Yesterday (20th June, 2024) Reserve Bank of India Governor was speaking at an event organised by the "College of Supervisors", on keeping the financial system resilient and crisis-immune. He urged banks "to avoid the mindless pursuit of bottom line". He also advised that "some profit driven business models may contain some hidden vulnerabilities, emphasising that profitability should not come at the expense of managing these risks".
"Risk Management comes before Bottom Line".
Have we come a full circle? For another time?
*****
To be fair to the Governor's guidance, he never said that profitability is not important. He only said that mindless pursuit of bottom line should not be made disregarding the risk aspects of unsecured lending, especially in the background of phenomenal growth in credit card dues to banks.
Profits are always the expected end products in any competitive business. We had a lot of fun when being a part of such meetings at different levels in the bank. A General Manager heading Credit (Loans) Department would urge to lend by taking risks as business would not grow unless we take risks and lend. A month later when he became General Manager of NPA portfolio, he would urge not to lend just to increase business as they create NPAs.
*****
Retirement and old age have their own advantages. We can look at all these developments from a distance and have a hearty laugh.